I wanted to write a technical post about a question I keep getting regarding the ketogenic diet and hypoglycemia. Even if you’re not into the keto diet, I think you may find some useful ideas to make low blood sugar less invasive in the short term. I recently shot a series of videos about the ketogenic diet and diabetes as part of my daily YouTube vlogging and you can check those out and subscribe here.
My general goal in my diabetes management is minimalism. Minimal intervention, treatment and daily impact. The most basic manifestation of this is to aim for the use of less insulin, which can create greater blood sugar stability. This strategy led me to a low carb diet. The need to have athletic performance in addition to the blood sugar stability led me one step further to the keto diet.
Using less insulin and eating fewer carbs means that lows do still happen but less frequently and they are easier to handle. Consider driving an empty truck down a hill. It’s going to be easier to stop than if it’s loaded down and has greater momentum. The same concept applies to insulin loads and slowing the “drop” of blood sugar. Simply lightening the load can simplify control of the vehicle.
When a low blood sugar occurs, the treatment ideally involves matching an increase in BG to the proportionate decrease in order to balance the two out. Therefore all hypo treatments are not created equal, or one treatment does not fit all lows- since different methods of raising blood sugar work differently.
One of the biggest obstacles to blood sugar stability is over correction of lows. Over correction can result from either the source of the treatment, the quantity of the treatment or a combination both factors. In other words, you don’t have to eat the entire pantry to overcorrect and spike. Sometimes following the 15×15 rule (eat 15g fast carbs, wait 15 minutes, test, repeat as necessary) can still yield the dreaded spike-which is now that much harder to bring down because you don’t want to overdo it and crash out-again.
The ideal treatment for a hypo is the smallest possible one. The hard part is figuring out how little you can get away with when you’re churning with adrenaline, in a cold sweat and panicking.
I’m suggesting that instead of always prioritizing the fastest treatment, prioritize the method of least intervention-when it’s possible to do so. There are certainly times when I’ll take glucose tabs or “fast sugar” of some kind, but those are typically emergency lows, not more benign lows. I classify my low blood sugars based on how fast I’m dropping because that correlates directly to the severity. Fast lows are treated as an emergency with emphasis on survival. Slow lows are treated with and emphasis on controlling the spike. In my 17 years I’ve used direct sugar sources (juice, glucose tabs, honey, candy, shot bloks etc) about 10-12% of all my lows, probably fewer than 150 “fast-low” incidents.
I draw on that experience to inform me as to what methods I should use to treat lows. This allows me to still correct low blood sugars without having them bounce high. I should add that as I’ve been on the Keto diet in the last year I’ve had ONE low that required fast sugar. The rest were managed with slower treatments that better matched the insulin action, resulting in little or no rebound spike (over 180mg/dL)
My go to treatments are all ones that CDEs would reject for having too much protein or fat: cashews, peanut butter, dark chocolate, ice cream (if I need more sugar but with a slower release), beef jerky. Obviously these won’t work with large doses of insulin and their corresponding BG fluctuations. When you bring the doses down, fluctuations narrow down and you find that these types of foods will work better in parallel with the action profile of the insulin.
I’ve tried fast sugars in much smaller amounts but they always cause a spike and that rapid increase makes me feel like there’s a brick in my stomach.
The question of how various hypo treatments impact ketosis leaves room for simple sugars as well as my preference of slower sugar. The amount of sugar (fast or slow) that it takes to raise a low while eating keto is relatively small and should not do more than possibly diminish ketosis for a few hours. I can frequently use protein to treat a low on the keto diet. Remember, more than the minimum required intake of protein will get converted to glucose-this is a sneaky fact that often wreaks havoc on unsuspecting people with diabetes! Treating a low blood sugar suspends ketosis temporarily and doesn’t require you to go back through the arduous process of keto-adaptation. You can resume ketosis in 12 hours or less with no major adverse effects.
Treating diabetes is risk management. Tighter control creates its own risks as does loosening up and letting the numbers stray a little further from the ideal. Knowing when to shift gears is key and building the experience gradually and carefully is an important investment in long term health. This isn’t a magic wand that will fix your blood sugar. It’s self experimentation that will help you calculate your risk more effectively-but never eliminate it. I can’t overemphasize the importance of looking at this process as an experiment. I’m presenting my results to encourage your own experimentation, not to replace any portion of it.
Stay connected.
Follow the Banting's Ghost documentary project and get Volume 2 of the AdventureRx Photo Journal as a FREE download when you subscribe!
Great post. I’ve been on a keto diet for 9 months and love it! It took awhile to adapt to the lack of variety , but the simplicity is wonderful. I’m a type 1 also.
Just a note of the site. When I read your posts on my iPhone the main body text is not centered and cuts off some letters on the right side.
Thank you! I am glad to hear that it’s been working out for you-and I will look into the issue with the posts. I have an iphone too but I haven’t experienced this problem. What browser are you using?
I’m using chrome on an iPhone 4 s.
Chrome on iphone 6p has no issues so I’m guessing it may be the hardware? I will have my web manager look into it! Thanks for the heads up!
I cannot even begin to express how delighted I am to find your blog and videos. Thank you for sharing your experience. I anticipate having a lot of questions for you, so I’ll introduce myself. I am a LADA T1 newly diagnosed a few months ago (though I was diagnosed with T2 about 4 years ago). Several years ago, I lost the weight (50#) I gained while carrying and birthing 3 babies in 4 years by doing a keto diet. Living with those three teenage boys now, we do have lots of “filler” (potatoes, rice, tortillas, etc.) in the house. However, once I was diagnosed as T2, I immediately cut most carbs out of my diet - you know those evil things I was eating, like brown rice and smoothies. Of course, it didn’t really make a difference since I was T1. (For some reason it took a long time for anyone to think I might be T1 even though I am 5’3″ and weighed 120# with a healthy diet and plenty of exercise.) I continued on the low carb path for a long time…until I sort of gave up and went back to eating things like brown rice, since I couldn’t achieve low blood glucose anyway. My main motivator right now (to be honest) is vanity. I gained 20 pounds in 3 weeks when I started taking insulin. Yikes! So now that I’ve introduced myself, here’s my question: when I do, say an hour of yoga flow, or go for a run, I have been covering that by eating an apple, or even a 50 carb smoothie, beforehand. Sometimes I still go low by the time I finish exercising, and sometimes I end up high, but more often than not, it’s covered pretty well. I am afraid, though, of how to handle this on a keto diet. If I am cruising along at, say, 110mg/dL, and I want to go to yoga class, where I know I could easily burn enough glucose to drop my level 100 points or more, what can be done to prevent a low?? Question 2: if I am in ketosis, and I eat an apple, say, which is immediately used up by my exercise, does that take me out of ketosis? And question 3: in order to avoid lows when transitioning and acclimating to ketosis, should one just not exercise at all? I appreciate any insight you can share from your experience!
Hi Greer-thank you for the kind words! I look forward to hearing from you about this experiment. I will do my best to answer your questions as I can.
1) I could give you my answer but that wouldn’t be useful because it’s a conclusion I’ve arrived at through my own experimentation. Everyone adapts differently. I would suggest doing a fraction of your normal workout for a few sessions to gauge your metabolic response. If it seems consistent with previously, then you either are not in ketosis and have to trouble-shoot that-or the keto diet may not work for you. It’s not always a fit for everyone. The key is to find these things out gradually and with low/correctable stakes. I suspect that will give you the answer you’re looking for-or something a lot closer to an answer than what I can tell you. My experience and that which I’ve heard from others too is that the huge drops with exercise are significantly mitigated. I’ve also heard others prepping for a low by eating pre workout and then winding up high when their BGs didn’t crater. Again, your mileage my vary-go slow and test often-and let us know your results!
2 If you are in ketosis, it’s unlikely that it will get used up by your exercise immediately because your exercise will be predominately fueled by ketones, not glucose so any uptake should occur at a much slower rate (you’d go high most likely if you’re in ketosis and ate an apple). It would at the very least diminish your ketone production temporarily. It could kick you out of ketosis for several hours but it would not break your bodies ability to burn ketones such that you’d have to redo the adaptation process because of one apple!
3 For a number of reasons I tend to recommend avoiding exercise while transitioning. The most pressing reason is that it’s always wise to avoid mixing variables. Exercise is a variable-as is ketosis-as is the transition period. The more deliberate you can be the better. Isolate variables! It’s not uncommon to “bonk” and get the keto flu-and often times it’s a bout of strenuous exercise that seems to trigger that. I’d wait until a week after the “dip” where you’re tired and feeling awful-and let the energy fully return before you start trying to use that energy. I think it’s fair to expect 2-4 weeks to be fully in ketosis and back up to speed of where you were on glucose.
It’s not an easy diet to get into and maintain but gradual and careful are two guide words that will help you test these questions further.
Glycerin is the thing to take when you are having hypoglycemic symptoms. It has zero effect on insulin and stabilizes blood sugar. Using any other forms of sugar to combat low blood glucose will just send u into a blood glucose rollercoaster.
I’ve never used glycerin-I actually don’t use sugar to treat lows. I use protein unless it’s a life threatening emergency for that reason (glucoaster). With tiny doses of insulin and no carb intake, such lows that require sugar have been virtually eliminated for me.
What about stopping insulin delivery on the pump for 30 minutes? I do that sometimes with slow lows or before exercise to avoid lows and works.
That’s a good idea too! I’m not a pumper but I’m glad to have that idea here for others who are!